joewrestler's blog
Part One: The Magazine on the Wall
At 53, I somehow found myself going down a rabbit hole into my own wrestling past. In the best order I can possibly recall all this.
I came across an old iPhone (first generation 2007 ), charged it up, and started looking through what was still on it. Before long, I was buried in old wrestling pictures, emails, and years-old conversations from the mid-2000s—messages about wrestling, trading pictures, and trying to arrange matches. It also led me to my Gmail address I had many years ago and I have created a folder "wrestling" to save correspondence, photos, and a few videos.
It was like opening a time capsule. And it got me thinking about where all of this started.
It's funny how something that seems completely random at the time can eventually become part of a much bigger story. For me, what put me on the path to discovering the wrestling community was a magazine in a Bronx bodega.
I knew from very early on that watching pro wrestling was a major turn-on for me, like many of us here. I just couldn't imagine the world I was going to discover years later.
I believe it was sometime in the early 2000s. I had spent the evening wandering around New York City – West Village. I used to do that a lot—walk around and quietly admire the queer world around me in the West Village.
I wasn't out as a gay man yet, but I very much wanted to be part of that world.
On my way home, I took the #2 train back to the Bronx and stopped at the bodega near White Plains Road and Pelham Parkway South, like I had done countless times before, to grab a soft drink and walk home.
High up on the wall was a large gay magazine. It was the kind of big, catalog-style magazine that immediately caught my attention. For whatever reason, I decided to buy it.
I remember being extremely nervous purchasing a magazine like that in public, with people around me. But I think I was getting to a point where I just didn't care anymore.
Inside was an advertisement for CAN-AM Wrestling. I couldn't believe what I was seeing.
What really caught my attention was the web address to the CAN-AM Wrestling website . The internet was still fairly new, and suddenly I had an address that seemed to lead to a world I didn't even know existed.
I couldn't wait to get to a computer.
Within a few days, I found one and typed in the address. It felt like I was unlocking a secret. I spent hours on that website and eventually ordered a few VHS tapes. When those packages arrived at my door, I swear it felt like I'd won the lottery.
Through CAN-AM, I discovered BG EAST and eventually a whole collection of other wrestling websites. Some were actual businesses, others were personal websites created by guys who were fascinated by wrestling and wanted to share their experiences and matches. I would also spend hours looking through Nick's Hillside Wrestling Camp weekends websites.
The early internet was strange that way. You could stumble across something incredibly specific and suddenly realize there was an entire community built around something you thought you were experiencing all by yourself.
So I wondered if I could find anyone in my area into wrestling. For whatever reason, I started looking on Craigslist. I found a few posts and spent weeks trying to build up the courage to respond. Eventually, I discovered guys actually looking to meet other guys for wrestling.
After some back-and-forth, I found myself out on Long Island meeting a guy for my first wrestling match. He turned out to be a really nice guy, and the experience was positive—and a lot of fun.
At some point while we were talking and just hanging in his condo, he showed me a wrestling personals website that many of us would come to know as "Global."
I couldn't believe how many guys from all over were on that website.
A few months later, I finally created my own profile. I was terrified.
I was still not out, and putting myself out there in this way felt like a pretty big step. But that profile introduced me to a whole new group of people, including NJWoodbridge, who became my first meeting and connection through the wrestling personals website.
We met and had a great time. Over the next few years, we met several more times, and he introduced me to other guys who eventually became regular wrestling buddies.
Looking back now, it's amazing to think about how much came from that one magazine.
A magazine led to a website.
The website led to VHS tapes.
The tapes led to more websites.
Those led to Craigslist.
Craigslist led to my first match.
And that first match led to friendships and a community I never knew existed.
But as I would eventually discover, those friendships were about to lead me somewhere much bigger than wrestling.
They were going to help me find a part of myself that I'd been keeping hidden for a very long time.
------------------------------------------------
I'm curious to know how some of you discovered this world...
I also find myself wanting to hold on to some of these things because, getting old I guess, not sure. Or is it all in the past and I should let it go – just keep the memories in my head as long as I can?
-------------------------------------------------
Next Post – Part Two
Grappling with Who I Am: How Wrestling Helped Me Come Out
Scooter (78 )
9/09/2026 5:28 PMThat is a cool story to read. I know I've been seeing you online as part of this community for as long as I can remember, and you're still one of the sexiest MFs on here. Thanks for sharing your story, and I'm glad you enjoyed the History page I made on the WFNYC site. If you, or anyone else wants to contribute to it, send me a message. :)
https://www.wrestlefestnyc.com/history
S~
SeattleFight (621)
9/08/2026 7:35 PMI think I was part of your early history, guapo - but maybe part 2 or 3. It is fun to reminisce like this and see how things have changed. Easier in most ways, for sure. Big bearhugs!
joewrestler (166)
9/08/2026 8:23 PM(In reply to this)
By the time I joined the wrestling sites, you were already one of those guys well-known and well-regarded as a 'super wrestling heavyweight', and still are :). I just realized we actually met in NYC (I want to say 2009) the first time, before I moved to the DC area, where I got to see you a few more times before you moved to the Northwest. Big bearhugs back!
SeattleFight (621)
9/08/2026 9:01 PM(In reply to this)
Yes we did first meet when you were still in NY. Hope to tangle with you again soon!
InkedRican (34)
9/08/2026 6:41 AMGreat Read/Share ! Thank you for posting. We share some similarities and that's pretty cool. Cheers !
Shootbig314 (53)
9/08/2026 12:35 AMVery similar story here, but I was a kid from the Midwest. I answered a newspaper personals ad from a guy who said he was into wrestling, and I remember being turned on by pro wrestling as a kid. He had some BG East tapes, and that was it. No going back. And as you said, getting one in the mail was the absolute best day ever. BG East catalogs too. It's amazing (and appreciated) how easy all of this is now.
joewrestler (166)
9/08/2026 3:17 PM(In reply to this)
Love that you answered a personals ad! I also love that we are of the generation that has witnessed and experienced technology up to what it is today. I find myself appreciating analog today.
I bet if I had looked or paid attention to newspaper/magazine personals, I would have found something back then. I remember NYC having so many alternative newspapers where I bet guys were posting wrestling ads.
herb (44)
9/08/2026 12:25 AMGreat post. Many of us over a certain age started along the sane lines. Long before internet, before pics you met on faith and hope. Thanks for sharing your story.
SFFight (84)
9/07/2026 11:39 PMMore blasts from the past... NickZ created a website for the original Hillside Wrestling Weekend that met in the . And to remind guys, MCIC is hosting year two of Camp Wretslefest in the Poconos in a few weeks (on the Events list for September 2026).
Enjoy NickZ's coverage of Hillside Wrestling Weekend with photo galleries from 1996 up to 2015.
https://www.eskimo.com/~nickz/hillside-f.html
NJWoodbridge (142)
9/07/2026 10:26 PMHey Jose, I think I was your first GlobalFight opponent, and I have appreciated our friendship ever since. And the several matches we had were always GREAT fun!
Your description of how your found this world is not much unlike my own. It was late 2001 and I had just had my second episode of a herniated disk at L5-S1. I had the three epidural injections and the immediate issue was resolved. Next was preventing it again and that meant regular exercise. Easier said then done since I had tried that before without much success at regular work outs. I did a lot of pondering about how I stayed in shape in my teen and college years and how I could recreate that. I pondered into one word - competition. Nothing crazy but just a little competition that would provide the incentive to stick to working out regularly.
So what competitive thing to do that operated year round, was accessible to office and home, and not a great expense. The "easily available" things like running distance held no interest for me; basketball was a good idea except I am bad at basketball (embarrassingly so). So I narrowed it down to 3 sports: tennis, swimming, and wrestling. I dismissed tennis quickly because it would involve joining a tennis club; but as anyone who knows me will say, I am not the tennis club type. Swimming was the best idea except the local pools only had competition for kids. I noticed more and more BJJ and wrestling schools opening up but at the time there were none in my town - what I noticed was just on the highways between my office and home. So I decided to try this new thing available: the internet and the newest search engine, Google.
So I type in my search request: wrestling schools in NJ. Everything that came up was for kids - including one in my town that I did not know about. But I knew from tv news shows that adults were getting into it so I changed by search inquiry to add the word "adult". The FIRST thing that popped up was BGEast, so I click on it and . . . . As I said above, you describe the initial feelings of "WOW" very well. From there, I found the predecessors to MeetFighters: Vangar, Global, Recon, and several others. The rest is history.
joewrestler (166)
9/07/2026 10:42 PM(In reply to this)
That's right, you were! And you introduced me to a few 'firsts' in wrestling... motel wrestling, small group wrestling, and NYC Wrestlefest – you'd invited me to a group meet-up — you had a room, and it turned into such a fun evening with a bunch of guys stopping by throughout the night :). Another 'first' was something that goes along with the second part of my story – we had happy hour drink(s) at the Boiler Room – first time at a gay bar :)
SFFight (84)
9/07/2026 10:14 PMI knew I was “different” from a young age and was obsessed with the TV show Bonanza (a house full of rabble rousing men of each male stereotype)… pro wrestling was not big yet and usually regional… I met a local Italian wrestler at my uncles’ Italian club… gregarious and big as life…
Fast forward to the late 1970s and living in Boston after college. I met a random bar pickup who turned out to be a former U.S. Judo team member. That night was my first experience. Unfortunately he moved away a week later and the pre-internet world gave me no other viable outlets.
A year later, a monthly gay magazine had an article on the NYWC (New York Wrestling Club) and its founder John Handley. A year later I met John Handley in NYC to purchase some quarterly newsletters with photos of members in matches. He asked if I wanted to roll and I quickly said yes. He was bigger and former military police but went easy on me.
I found my first wrestle buddie from those newsletters and we would meet when I visited NYC. Then the internet introduced me to AOL wrestlingm4m chat room that started my path to where I am now.
For anyone interested… I worked with Scooter and NickZ to digitize our combined NYWC newsletter library and included that article on the NYWC and John Handley for the 2026 NYC Wrestlefest. We made it available on the NYC Wrestlefest website under the History link from About Us. You can download the PDF file (and if opened with navigation panel it has a table of contents for easier navigation).
https://www.wrestlefestnyc.com/history
joewrestler (166)
9/07/2026 10:22 PM(In reply to this)
Thank you so much for sharing this — what an incredible piece of history, from Bonanza and your uncle's Italian club all the way to John Handley and the NYWC newsletters. I really appreciate you tracing that whole journey. Thank you for sharing the link!
SFFight (84)
9/07/2026 10:31 PM(In reply to this)
Thanks for starting this blog…
As I said, this was initiated by Scooter in collaboration with me and NickZ… it’s important to know where we came from to appreciate where we are and continue forward… this is an awesome community.
synxiec (95)
9/07/2026 10:10 PMThis looks like it's going to be a lot of fun to read, so looking forward to it.